By: Susan and Peter Martin

Best of the Best Award Recipient

Every now and then, you find a restaurant that quietly earns a place in your life, not through one perfect meal, but through consistency, comfort, and the feeling that it simply gets everything right. For us, Green Papaya in St. Johns is exactly that kind of place.

We still remember the first time we walked in more than two years ago. Susan immediately noticed the soft lighting in the side dining room and said it felt like the perfect date night spot, and she was right. The ambiance strikes a balance that is not easy to achieve. It feels polished without being formal, comfortable without losing its sense of occasion. It is the kind of place where you settle in, slow down, and enjoy the moment.

On this visit, we came in hungry and ready to revisit a favorite. We started with the sampler appetizer, which is always a smart way to begin. The spring rolls were crisp and light, the coconut shrimp carried just the right touch of sweetness, the chicken skewers were tender and flavorful, and the crab rangoon delivered that creamy, satisfying bite we both look for.

Susan, as expected, went straight for the Tom Kha soup. It brings a noticeable spice, layered and warming, with a depth that keeps you coming back for another spoonful. We always suggest being mindful of the spice level, but for those who enjoy bold flavor, it is a standout.

As sushi lovers, we have worked our way through nearly every specialty roll on the menu over the years, and what continues to impress us is the consistency. On this visit, the Tiger Roll stopped us both after the first bite. It earned a place on our “Best of the Best” list, a recognition we reserve for dishes that truly stay with us. The balance of flavor, the texture, and the precision made it unforgettable.

We also explored the Tropical Roll, featuring spicy scallops, mango, and white tuna. It is a combination that feels both creative and well thought out. The mango adds a natural sweetness that softens the spice, creating a balance that works beautifully.

Service at Green Papaya always brings a bit of personality. The team is attentive and welcoming, and there is a playful twist with the robot that helps deliver food. Our grandchildren love it, although we will admit it can interrupt a quiet conversation from time to time. Still, it is part of what makes the experience unique.

In terms of value, Green Papaya sits firmly in the upscale sushi category. This is not the place to cut corners, and that is exactly why it works. The quality of the ingredients and the consistency of execution justify the price, especially for those who appreciate what great sushi should be.

Green Papaya has become one of our Favorite Tables Around Town, not because of one standout visit, but because it continues to deliver the kind of experience we look forward to sharing together. It is a place where we know we will leave satisfied, already talking about when we will return.

Star Rating:
★★★★★